Hi there, welcome to our blog!

We're Dwayne and Hanna,
compulsive readers whose
growing book collection sadly
lacks a bookshelf.

We're 23 and 15, and we live in London.

Like most sisters, we bicker. A lot.

27 August 2010

Spoiler Free Book Review: Mockingjay (Suzanne Collins)


Against all odds, Katniss Everdeen has survived the Hunger Games twice. But now that she's made it out of the bloody arena alive, she's still not safe. The Capitol is angry. The Capitol wants revenge...

So, Mockingjay. I'm not going to lie - I am addicted, obsessed and completely loyal to this trilogy, so my review is reflective of that - but even so let me tell you, this book did not exactly bring me joy. It evokes a lot of emotions, yes but I was crying not smiling at the end of it.

Mockingjay stays true to its dystopian origins. While a lot will not agree with me, I feel that the grimness of the book is a part of its strength. In true dystopian fashion, it explores the downfall of human conscience and displays the worse of our attributes; like Hunger Games and Catching Fire, I was appalled by many of the events in the book and at points felt sick at the ability of the characters to act as cruelly as they do. At times I felt that Mockingjay borders on unbearable - exactly how grim can a book be? It seems that nothing close to happily ever after can be associated with this book, because believe me, it can be depressing.

I can't help but comment on all the political implications on this book, because the trilogy is far beyond just Katniss' story. The workings of the rebellion and the fight for freedom takes a bulk of the book and the tension spirals out of control in many of its pages.As the mockingjay, Katniss traverses the thin line that divides both sides. I love the twisted, wicked feel of the battle because that was exactly how I imagined it to be. Not only full of secrets, but full of dark aims and uncertainties.

There is a lot I can say about how the characters' fates are sealed. We know beforehand that there will be deaths; what we do not know is who will die. Or exactly how many. As it turns out, no number of speculations could possibly have prepared me for the depressing turn of events in Mockingjay. Unfair will not even begin to cover what I think, because really I felt as if the characters were oppressed. Their circumstances were too heavy to comprehend experiencing, and the book does not give them what happiness they were due. The strength of characters is evident here, as clearly as their weaknesses. At this point, we readers are already very attached to the characters, so extreme reactions are expected. When I found out exactly who dies, I literally screamed and cried and wished the words changed. It was not supposed to happen, that was my primary reaction. There was a sense of hopelessness and helplessness and surely, you have got to be kidding? I felt as if I was killed right along with the character(s).

It was even more painful to read about the fates of those who were indirectly responsible for those deaths. And while I was not happy with the decisions of some of the major characters, I can understand the rationale behind it. It was not easy to pretend to be in their shoes and emphatise, but to comprehend the depth of pain and grief is, and that understanding is what makes it seem like a true decision. Depressing, but I felt that the portrayal of the damages to the human persona is not only accurate but also vivid, I believe Mockingjay stays true to its origins.

The ending I felt is slightly too rushed for my liking and too much too short. I am not sure I approve with what happened to some of the major characters, because towards the end I felt the need to know more about how they fared. I needed details, further insights and I don't think that was exactly granted. The ending is open to interpretations and leaves a lot to the reader to ponder and imagine. It is not happy per se, but as close to happiness as a dystopian trilogy like this one can be. I'm going to go ahead and say that the ending be-fits the feel of the trilogy. Had it been a flowery happy ever after, I would have much disliked it, because then it would appear as if it was only made to please the readers. It's not the best possible ending, but I can envision it happening following the events of Mockingjay. So it is a neat ending I guess. Still, I needed more!

I'm sure Mockingjay is part evil - it gave me such a terrible case of withdrawal once I finished that I did not know what to say or do - and that was on top of all the other emotions the events in the book evoked! There was a sense of 'now what?' that hovered over me when it was over, and I was emotionally-drained. Which means it's a good book, a great trilogy and a worthy read. Which means I am still hooked to it, and will probably always be. Which means Katniss' story is unmissable. Prepare to scream, kick and cry with this final book.

FIVE STARS.

PS. Hunger Games Fanfictions, anyone? Already I see a lot of readers writing alternative endings:)

6 comments:

Liz. R said...

I agree about the ending. I would have liked to know more about what happened to some of the characters. To tell you the truth, I don't know what to think. This book was so different to the others and it was so difficult to read; I can't even imagine being Katniss. So many horrible things happened, so many things hard to accept. I don't know whether this is my least favourite or whether it's the one I should like the most.

The last line, though. Pure awesomeness.

Dwayne said...

@Liz: God, I agree! And okay, so maybe I didn't pay attention to that line very much (can you blame me? I was in tatters at that point, and was playing with whomever was playing, lol) but yess you're so right. Totally Hunger Games that one :)

Niki V. said...

I had similiar feelings as you did.

What I think is that we all expected way too much of this last book, but at the end we are all pleased with what happened.

This is one great trilogy and I know I'll re-read it again :)

About fanfiction: I really love to write, but I'm sooooooooooooo faaaaaaaaaaaaaar away from Suzanne's writing...she is the best, really.

BTW: I have rewarded you with One Lovely Blog Award :)

Liz. R said...

I was practically in tears by the end, which is saying something because not a lot of books make me cry. I feel like the characters were cheated - so much was so unfair! But then it wouldn't be The Hunger Games if everything was fine and dandy. Still. I feel like I need a whole other book just to explain how characters reconciled and went back to normal, and what happened to other characters and so on. That ending, whilst fitting, just wasn't enough for me.

Ryan said...

It is very emotional. That bit near the end (you'll know what I mean ;)) had me in tears. Very depressing book but equally amazing. Had a knot in my stomach at the end. You really feel it! The ending was a little rushed, I wished we learned more about some of the characters, but I thought the Epilogue was BRILLIANT! That last line is amazing!

tumblenc said...

*agrees*
I think we've been waiting for emotional closure the whole series, but we don't really get it in mockingjay.

Post a Comment

Statistics




Since 06 September 2010